|The International Visibility of
Danish and Scandinavian Research 19881996.
Peter Ingwersen. Centre for Information Studies, Royal School of Library and Information Science, Copenhagen, Denmark. [CIS Report No. 5], 1998. p. 72.
Davidson Frame had suggested a few years ago that if one wanted to measure the volume of significant research performed by different countries, one could count the number of papers indexed in Science Citation Index (SCI), but if one wanted to make a more comprehensive survey then one could use comprehensive subject databases. In the early eighties, Udai N. Singh of Birla Institute of Technology, Ranchi, collected publication data from INSPEC-Physics Abstracts and citation data from the print version of SCI to map the impact of hitech physics research holography, lasers, liquid crystals and superconductivity in India, Israel, Canada and Australia. Singh collected the entire data manually! Peter Ingwersen has carried out an online publication analysis for Scandinavian countries, combining comprehensive abstracting services BIOSIS, Medline, Chemical
Abstracts, Psychinfo, INSPEC, and Compendex and the three multidisciplinary citation indexes SCI, SSCI, and A and HCI. Like Paul Bourke and Linda Butler have done for Australia and Steven Katz and Diana Hicks have done for the UK, Ingwersen has provided quantitative publication indicators for Denmark and Scandinavia. While the Australian and the British colleagues devoted much time to standardize data elements, Ingwersen provides two types of publication indicators, viz. the Gross International Visibility (GIV) and the Central International Visibility (CIV) for all of science in Denmark as well as for nine central scientific domains. For Finland, Norway and Sweden he has provided only CIV. The GIV is the annual publication activity relative to the world (or regional) activity monitored by means of the core international bibliographic databases (such as BIOSIS for Biology) and citation databases. CIV is limited to publications indexed in ISIs citation databases. Ingwersen has tried hard to isolate entries that may be found both in one of the citation indexes and in the domain-dependent databases, to avoid duplicate counting. He has also compared his data with TemaNord report on science in the OECD countries, published in 1994.
Besides giving data on Scandinavias share of the worlds publications, Ingwersen provides an idea of publication productivity (in relation to expenditure on R and D). Scandinavia is strong in the life sciences, and particularly in biomedicine, with a 30% higher average publication activity, but weak in chemistry. For those who would like to have a quick glance, Ingwersens two-page summary (Chapter 12) can give a clear idea of the major results. The large number of tables, figures, and bar charts also help. The subjects and subfields constituting the nine central domains (biology, biomedicine, clinical medicine, social medicine, chemistry, geoscience, physics and mathematics, technology, social sciences and humanities) are given in an appendix.
There are some methodological problems. Ingwersen has used Medline as the core subject dependent database for both biomedicine and clinical medicine. But the numbers of Medline entries from Denmark differ: 23,954 in the section on biomedicine (page 26) and 12,969 in the section on clinical medicine (page 30). Besides, not all Medline entries can be credited to either biomedicine or clinical medicine. Physics and mathematics are clubbed and Inspec is used as the core subject database. The author could have tried Mathsci or Compumath Citation Index as a core bibliographic database for Mathematics.
The book does not explain the data collection and analysis methods in detail, perhaps because the author has described them in the two journal articles given in the references section on page 62. The writing style in general could have been improved with the help of an editor.
I look forward to the authors forthcoming report on international citation impacts of Scandinavian science.
MS Swaminathan Research Foundation
Taramani, 3rd Cross Street
Chennai 600 013, India
BACK TO NON-FRAMES CONTENTS
BACK TO FRAMES CONTENTS